Geneseo Models Utility Rate Increases as Major Infrastructure Projects Approach

by Sarah DeMaranville
Geneseo Current

Geneseo residents could see gradual increases in water, sewer, and electric bills as the city prepares for millions of dollars in infrastructure work, including projects the city says are mandated by environmental regulations.

Those requirements include replacing lead service lines by 2047 and completing wastewater improvements needed to meet phosphorus discharge requirements, including a 2030 phosphorus target.

City officials also point out that Geneseo is not insulated from rising construction material and labor costs affecting utility organizations across the country. Together, regulatory requirements, aging infrastructure, and increasing project costs are contributing to the city's long-term utility needs.

City officials say long-term planning could help avoid larger rate increases later by spreading costs over time.

During the Sept. 22 Committee of the Whole meeting, council members reviewed the city's 2027 capital plan and financial projections from Waterworth, a utility rate-management and forecasting platform.

No utility rates were approved during the discussion.

Instead, Waterworth modeled what the city's finances could look like under several scenarios involving future projects, debt, operating expenses, grants, and utility revenue.

The primary scenario included 5% increases for water and wastewater rates in 2027. Residential electric usage rates would increase approximately 2%, while residential base charges would remain unchanged.

For a household using approximately 3,000 gallons of water and 700 to 1,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity each month, the combined increase was estimated at roughly $6 per month, or approximately 3% overall.

Actual rates will return to the council for consideration.

Lead service lines increase projected costs

One of the biggest changes from the city's previous financial projections involves lead service lines.

The replacement program is not a discretionary city infrastructure project. City officials say the work is an EPA mandate, and Geneseo is required to have its lead service lines replaced by 2047.

City officials said as many as roughly 50% of Geneseo's water services could ultimately require replacement because of lead or other qualifying materials. The city has approximately 3,310 water services and is currently using an estimate of about 2,000 potential replacements for financial planning.

Staff discussed replacing approximately 6% of affected services annually. If the final number were approximately 2,000, that would mean roughly 120 replacements each year.

At an estimated average cost of $5,000 per service, the city is now planning for approximately $600,000 annually for lead service line replacements — twice the $300,000 included in earlier projections.

The Waterworth representative said that increase is one reason the latest model uses a 5% water rate increase rather than the 3% to 4% previously considered.

"In our previous rate plans, we were going for about 3 to 4% initially, but as mentioned, we had increased our budget from $300,000 for lead line replacement [to] $600,000," the representative said. "So, to make sure that we stay afloat using those percentages, we went with a 5%."

What would 5% mean for a water bill?

For an inside-city residential customer with a three-quarter-inch meter using approximately 3,000 gallons of water per month, Waterworth showed a current monthly water bill of approximately $44.

A 5% adjustment would add approximately $2 per month to the water portion of that bill.

Councilman Brett Barnhart acknowledged that even relatively small increases come as residents are already facing higher costs elsewhere.

"There's so many rising costs," Barnhart said. "It's hard."

City Administrator Brandon Maeglin also noted that the city itself is not insulated from rising costs. Construction materials and labor have become more expensive for utility organizations across the country, increasing the cost of maintaining, replacing, and upgrading public infrastructure.

The discussion then turned to whether smaller, more regular adjustments could prevent much larger increases later.

Councilman Craig Arnold said he preferred addressing necessary increases gradually rather than putting them off.

"I'd rather eat it small, in little chunks, and still be above board," Arnold said. "I think that's the right thing to do."

Mayor Sean Johnson made a similar point, saying increases of 3% to 5% when necessary are easier to absorb than keeping rates unchanged for several years and eventually facing an increase of 10% or 15%.

More water projects are ahead

Lead service lines aren't the city's only anticipated water expense.

Waterworth identified approximately $5.7 million in water infrastructure backlog, although the representative cautioned that the number is an estimate and does not mean the city needs to immediately spend $5.7 million.

"It could be less than this," the representative said. "The idea is that there is a backlog."

The city is also planning for a future water treatment project estimated at approximately $8.5 million. That project has been moved from 2027 to 2028 in the capital plan.

Other planned projects include approximately 1,500 feet of new 10-inch water main along the U.S. 6 corridor from the Dillenbeck Drive area toward Hanford Drive.

The approximately $550,000 project would use roughly $350,000 from the U.S. 6 Tax Increment Financing District and approximately $200,000 from the water utility.

The city also plans to create a water-main loop serving the Route 82 industrial park area. The existing line dead-ends. Connecting it to another portion of the system would improve water circulation and provide additional flexibility within the system.

Grants could help

The city's basic financial projections assume it receives no grant funding for the work. That allows officials to plan for a scenario in which the city must cover the costs itself rather than budgeting money it may never receive.

Waterworth also modeled what could happen if Geneseo receives approximately $300,000 per year in grant assistance beginning in 2028. That would cover about half of the projected $600,000 annual lead service line replacement expense.

If grants are received, the city could potentially use the additional money to complete replacements more quickly rather than immediately reducing rates.

The city is budgeting approximately $50,000 for engineering work in 2027 to prepare for potential water infrastructure grants in 2028.

Staff said portions of Geneseo may qualify for grant programs targeted toward low-to-moderate-income areas.

Reserves are part of the equation

Waterworth's projections aren't based only on whether the utility has enough money to pay its bills each year. The city also needs reserves for unexpected expenses and future debt. The model uses an operating threshold based on approximately six months of operating expenses and six months of debt service.

Without adequate rate adjustments, Waterworth's projections show the water utility's cash reserves declining substantially over the next several years.

The modeled 5% increase puts the water fund in a stronger position to pay for projects while maintaining reserves.

Old debt is ending as new projects approach

Some of Geneseo's existing water debt is nearing the end of its repayment schedule. Existing water debt has historically cost roughly $300,000 per year, with much of that debt expected to fall away around 2028. However, new projects would bring new debt. Waterworth projects that new water-related debt payments could eventually approach approximately $600,000 annually.

That means the city could retire one generation of debt at roughly the same time it begins financing another generation of infrastructure.

Mayor Johnson said having long-term financial projections gives the city information it hasn't always had when making those decisions.

"So often we were making determinations without this type of data," Johnson said.

The modeling allows the city to look several years ahead, incorporating anticipated projects and their costs rather than waiting until those expenses arrive.

Wastewater has major mandated costs ahead, too

Geneseo's wastewater system faces even larger projected infrastructure needs.

Waterworth identified approximately $22 million to $22.5 million in wastewater infrastructure backlog. As with the water figure, that does not mean all of the work must be completed immediately.

The largest upcoming project is a phosphorus-removal project at the wastewater treatment plant, currently estimated at approximately $10 million to $10.5 million.

The project has been moved to 2028 in the capital plan.

According to information provided by the city, the phosphorus-removal work is an EPA-mandated requirement. Under a 2018 agreement between the Illinois EPA, the Illinois Association of Wastewater Agencies, and environmental groups, major municipal wastewater treatment plants with a design average flow of 1 million gallons per day are expected to meet a total phosphorus limit of 0.5 milligrams per liter beginning Jan. 1, 2030.

That means the phosphorus project cannot simply be postponed indefinitely as an optional capital improvement. The city must prepare its wastewater system to meet the applicable discharge requirements.

The city previously sought loan-forgiveness assistance but did not initially qualify. Officials may pursue additional funding opportunities if they become available.

Current wastewater debt service is approximately $650,000 annually and is expected to decline before new project debt is added. Financing the phosphorus project could eventually add approximately $800,000 in annual debt payments.

Waterworth modeled a 5% wastewater rate increase. For a household using approximately 3,000 gallons per month, that would add roughly $2.50 to the monthly wastewater bill.

Electric increases would be structured differently

The electric utility would not receive an across-the-board 3% rate increase under the model.

Residential base charges would remain unchanged, while residential electricity usage rates would increase approximately 2%. Commercial classes would see larger percentage adjustments, with the overall goal of increasing electric utility revenue approximately 3%. For residential customers, Waterworth estimated an increase of approximately $1.50 per month for someone using 700 kilowatt-hours and about $2 per month at 1,000 kilowatt-hours.

The electric utility also faces future equipment, distribution, generation, and substation projects.

As with the city's water and wastewater systems, the cost of completing those projects is affected by construction material and labor prices.

What does it mean for the average bill?

Taken together, Waterworth estimated the modeled changes would add approximately $6 per month to the city utility bill of a household using 3,000 gallons of water and 700 kilowatt-hours of electricity.

That works out to approximately a 3% overall increase — not a 5% increase to the entire utility bill.

Individual bills would vary depending on water and electricity usage, meter size, and customer classification.

Planning now to avoid larger increases later

The broader issue facing the council is how to pay for infrastructure that will need to be replaced or upgraded over the coming years.

Some of the city's largest anticipated expenses are driven by requirements outside the city's control. Lead service line replacements are mandated, with the city required to complete replacements by 2047, and the wastewater system must meet phosphorus discharge requirements.

At the same time, Geneseo faces aging water infrastructure, electric system improvements, and other capital needs.

City officials also emphasize that Geneseo does not operate in isolation from broader economic conditions. Higher construction material and labor costs affecting utility organizations across the country also affect what Geneseo pays to complete its projects.

The city can use a combination of utility revenue, reserves, grants, and borrowing to pay for that work.

"Our whole goal is to keep it consistent," the Waterworth representative told the council. "Rates are going to go up. That's the unfortunate reality as everything else does."

Mayor Johnson said increases in the range of 3% to 5% when necessary are easier to absorb than keeping rates unchanged for several years and then confronting a much larger increase.

The numbers presented Sept. 22 are not set in stone. Waterworth's model can be updated as the city learns more about project costs, lead service lines, grant funding, construction and labor costs, and other expenses. Grants or lower-than-anticipated costs could improve the financial picture, while higher construction costs, unexpected repairs, or unsuccessful grant applications could increase future needs.

For now, the projections give the council a look at what the next several years could cost and how today's rate decisions could affect the city's ability to pay for that work.

No final utility rates were approved Sept. 22. Those rates will return to the council for consideration.